Want feedback on your Soundcloud tracks???

[GumsOfGabby]

http://listenpledge.com/

This website pairs you up with another artist's track to provide feedback for one another.

Please don't cheat the system and write 2 word, half arsed reviews. Give good feedback and (hopefully) get good feedback. Go nuts!

[Kushy Kallous]

Thanks!
Seems really interesting and worth checking out for random music. : )

edit: Got some feedback nice and quick with this!
Great find. ; )

[phaux]

Doesn't allow timed comments

[5COPY]

Doesn't allow timed comments

Hur, yeah it does it's just we got each others tracks and I lost internet and forgot to feedback.

The sides lock the user onto a song i fthey haven't feedbacked yet

[GumsOfGabby]

Doesn't allow timed comments

Hur, yeah it does it's just we got each others tracks and I lost internet and forgot to feedback.

The sides lock the user onto a song i fthey haven't feedbacked yet

I think what phaux meant was that you can't comment on the timeline (blue bar underneath the Soundcloud player).

I think don't think it's THAT much of a loss to be honest.

[Nine Volt]

Nice find, will probably be using it!

[Lavender_Harmony]

Gave it a try, feedback I got was pretty lamesauce if I'm honest, one line.

[Nine Volt]

Got one feedback almost immediately, it was pretty thorough, like a paragraph long. The others two haven't gotten feedback though >:(

[5COPY]

Most of the feedback i've gotten aren't very constructive but I guess it's good if you want to see if you're doing decent. Or to help you find a very obvious mistake that you just didn't think about.

[GumsOfGabby]

Gave it a try, feedback I got was pretty lamesauce if I'm honest, one line.

That's expected, given the majority of the Soundcloud population.

Got one feedback almost immediately, it was pretty thorough, like a paragraph long. The others two haven't gotten feedback though >:(

Atleast you got some decent feedback The other artists can't apply for another round of pairing until they give you feedback. So just be patient.

Most of the feedback i've gotten aren't very constructive but I guess it's good if you want to see if you're doing decent. Or to help you find a very obvious mistake that you just didn't think about.

Yeah, this program is probably going to end up with 90% of users commenting "cool track" or "awesome!" or ":D" just to make their tracks look better. Because for some reason people seem to think that - more comments = better track.

[Anorax]

this looks like a pretty good idea, although it seems that you can't get another pairing until your paired person comments on your track. maybe the freeze goes both ways?

EDIT: eh, maybe not. Either way, I post a nice paragraph and a half on this one guy's track and get this back:
"nice shit going on, keep this up!"

Well, at least he heard it

[Lavender_Harmony]

This is just making me miss garageband.com. That was a really good resource...

[Anorax]

[necro bump]
Man, I forgot about this.

I also found a similar site, called Cloudkillers or something like that, which basically puts your song into a queue. Then, everyone is given a random song, which they have to post at least one comment on. Once they finish, they have a second song to listen to, and so on and so forth. All the while, your own song is going through the queue system getting comments.

And users can't simply post "nice" as the comment because they have active moderators that will ban users who do so


Basically, as long as you post comments, you'll get comments